Print Story 2007.02.12: Not quite a genius-level haiku
Diary
By BlueOregon (Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 08:44:13 PM EST) (all tags)
[at] [the wreck] [we] [stare];
[Crazy is] [as crazy does] ...
[Raise your fist and yell]

Inside: GPotD, and that's about it.



I

“Der Schwan” (1905–06)

Diese Mühsal, durch noch Ungetanes
schwer und wie gebunden hinzugehn,
gleicht dem ungeschaffnen Gang des Schwanes.

Und das Sterben, dieses Nichtmehrfassen
jenes grunds, auf dem wir täglich stehn,
seinem ängstlichen Sich-Niederlassen—:

in die Wasser, did ihn sanft empfangen
und die sich, wie glücklich und vergangen,
unter ihm zurückziehn, Flut um Flut;
während er unendlich still und sicher
immer mündiger und königlicher
und gelassener zu ziehn geruht.

—By Rainer Maria Rilke

Leishman's translation (below) is faithful enough to retain much that is poetic with Rilke's version, but the at once awkward and elegant constructions—e.g. Nichtmehrfassen—in German are merely awkward in English (“no more hold-providing”), perhaps a tad ironic in a poem about grace.

And death.

It's a gentle twist on the subject. Leishman maintains the macro-level rhetorical & poetic structure.

II

This afternoon after class L suggested I attach a timer to my baked goods so as to see how long it takes for them to disappear. I'm not sure the banana bread was “all that,” but I must admit that it had not only a fine flavor but a fine texture, and it was seemingly appreciated by quite a few residents of our madhouse, our Irrenanstalt, if you will.

Irrenhaus oder Irrenanstalt ist eine veraltete, heute als abwertend empfundene und nur noch in der Umgangssprache gebräuchliche Bezeichnung für eine psychiatrische Klinik.

My dorm in Marburg used to belong to the psychiatric clinic; it was easy to be locked into your room or even your hall. There was an office at the entry, and while it at that time occasionally housed someone to make sure only the right people entered, you got the feeling that it had once served the opposite purpose.

I suggest moving all the psychiatric wards to Halle, Bitterfeld, and Magdeburg, and rename the state Sachsen-Anstalt.

I have more Good Eats to watch, but I won't begin watching it for a while. Torchwood is now ready for consumption, but it, too, will wait, for tonight is Heroes.

I eventually left the building after a good chat with the former chair about 3rd-year pedagogy and the current materials available. We're both critical of what's out there and have a few ideas for some in-house improvements.

Alvin Goldman's Simulating Minds: the Philosophy, Psychology, and Neuroscience of Mindreading (Oxford UP, 2006) is a fine volume but at points dryly unreadable. I'm not sure why I ever checked it out in the first place. Chapter 8, “Ontogeny, Autism, Empathy, and Evolution,” was, in the end, the only thing that interested me. It was impossible not to enjoy the following sentence from page 195:

Psycholinguistic research shows that among the child's earliest words are “uh-oh” and (in England) “oh bugger.”

The section on role-playing interested me a bit, primarily because of its pedagogical relevance. The book was recalled on me, so after photocopying a chapter I returned it to the library.

Up to Fair Trade I strolled, saw my sorry reflection once or twice in the glass, and determined that I need a haircut. The coffee shop was curiously not full and I found a table against the wall and an outlet. I made it through a few chapters further in Something Rotten; perhaps post-Heroes I'll finish it. The crowd tended toward the polite, reserved, and quiet today; few mouth-breathers or cell-phone conversation broadcasters. Alas, the people-watching opportunities were limited.

Since A's new girlfriend, M, works at Westfield Comics, why not pimp one of the few comic shops in Madison?

T told tales of driving back from Texas to Wisconsin via Missouri this weekend and mentioned that the roadside signage in that state is as scary as ever.

III

Sure, I find “through the still-to-do” a poetically weak rendition of “durch noch Ungetanes” and I've commented on “no more hold-providing” already, but the bit that bugs me is the insertion of commas toward the end. English speakers tend to throw in commas for all sorts of verbal pauses; Germans do not. The addition of commas after “maturely” and “composedly” has two effects: the spoken flow in the German is here broken up, and what was a series of three parallel modifiers is now two modifiers and a parenthetical aside, an appositive of sorts, that is equivalent to the previous expression. Leishman also removed an and, and perhaps he felt the lack of commas and use of several ands lent the verse a run-on flavor, but I'm all for the run-on here.

“The Swan”

This laborious going on and on,
bound and heavy, through the still-to-do is
like the unshaped walking of the swan.

Dying, too, that no more hold-providing
by the ground we daily trusted to, is
like his so unconfident subsiding

into waters that receive him gently
and, as though departed and contently,
wave on wave retire from under him;
while he, infinitely still and surely,
ever kinglier and more maturely,
more composedly, condescends to swim.

—Translated by J.B. Leishman
< One simple question... | BBC White season: 'Rivers of Blood' >
2007.02.12: Not quite a genius-level haiku | 5 comments (5 topical, 0 hidden) | Trackback
Roadside signage by toxicfur (2.00 / 0) #1 Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 09:00:03 PM EST
That's a cruel teaser. Are they merely signs for tourist traps and evangelical store-front churches? Or are there true gems like the black-and-white signs purporting to quote God? E.g., "Don't make me come down there. --God."
-----
inspiritation: the effect of irritating someone so much it inspires them to do something about it. --BuggEye


the scary combination ... by BlueOregon (2.00 / 0) #2 Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 09:20:49 PM EST

... of big big signs for adult toy stores alternated with signs about how PORN KILLS AND YOU ARE GOING TO HELL!!!! plus the normal car dealership ads, of course. Mile after mile after mile.

_
"The german quoting guy is a little bit out there." (fleece)
[ Parent ]

On comic shops by aethucyn (2.00 / 0) #3 Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 10:54:04 PM EST
I'm not a huge comic reader. I read some of the superhero books when I was a kid, but never followed anything. Just had the basic familiarity of who a lot of the characters were. But a few years back, I got into some bits of comics and graphic novels etc. I was following a couple of titles on Slave Labor Graphics, so when I lived in Vegas, I'd walk down to my local shop. Basic strip mall location, but it was a decent shop, which wasn't crammed too full. In a clever bit of marketing, titles that attracted folks like me tended to be in front, while the bulk of Marvel and DC tended to be in the back, since those guys would know what they want, and go through anything to get to them. What I also liked was that the guy who ran the place had good taste in music, which is to say my taste. So, I'd come in and realize that I was listening to an album I hadn't heard in years. I also twice bumped into him at concerts, Aimee Mann and David Byrne, which just made him cool in my book. But best of all was that he was really good at picking out things that I'd be interested in. I read "Persepolis" at his instruction, and when the second book came out, he held a copy behind the counter for me without my having asked (he did the same for me when "In the Shadow of No Towers" by Spiegelman came out). It got to the point where I'd go there every week on my days off, just because it was a pleasant way to kill some time. Since I've moved, I've pretty much stopped buying comics. I think the only ones I've bought was the "Polly and the Pirates" series. I've tried different places around, but I always feel like I'm on a strange planet. Maybe we can convince Kellnerin to make it be a publishing house/coffee shop/library/comic store on a train.



I could be convinced ... by Kellnerin (2.00 / 0) #4 Mon Feb 12, 2007 at 11:16:17 PM EST
except that I am personally comics-stupid (although I do have a slim "graphic novel" about Buddhism in Hebrew ... which I can't read of course.) Maybe if bo would agree to be the comics/graphic novel buyer, it could be done.

--
"If a tree is impetuous in the woods, does it make a sound?" -- aethucyn
[ Parent ]

I know you're scared of the 'burbs, by toxicfur (2.00 / 0) #5 Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 07:12:50 AM EST
but New England Comics in Malden Center reminds me of the shop you describe. It's comfortable, the staff is knowledgeable, and it's utterly unlike one shop I went to in Harvard Square once, where the guy behind the counter didn't even look up from his book when I asked him a question. At New England Comics, I bought Pride of Baghdad based off staff recommendation (he saw I was buying something else by Vaughan and went to get it for me).

There's another New England Comics in Coolidge Corner that I've been into a few times, usually finding just what I'm looking for. The last time I went in there, a rather attractive (in that geeky kind of way) woman was working behind the counter. She helped me find what I was looking for and gave me a piece of homemade banana bread, too.
-----
inspiritation: the effect of irritating someone so much it inspires them to do something about it. --BuggEye
[ Parent ]

2007.02.12: Not quite a genius-level haiku | 5 comments (5 topical, 0 hidden) | Trackback